My account
Free US Shipping $35+ - Free International Over $75 USD

Geeky Baking Goodies!

Mario Item Cookie Cutters - Super Mushroom, Fire Flower, Coin, Shell, Super Crown

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE You've collected them for years but now you can eat them! E...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE You've collected them for years but now you can eat them! Enjoy these iconic Mario items that still power-up our favorite plumber to this day! Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to possible cross contamination, allergy, and food use issues. All sales are final on this product, regardless of opened or unopened status. This is for the health of all our custome...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Nintendo Controller Cookie Cutters - Gamecube, Switch, SNES, NES, N64

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Your childhood brought to life in beautiful edible form, ma...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Your childhood brought to life in beautiful edible form, make some controllers, eat some controllers. Just don't decorate them like MadCatz ;) Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to possible cross contamination, allergy, and food use issues. All sales are final on this product, regardless of opened or unopened status. This is for the health of all our custome...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Mario Odyssey Cookie Cutters - Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Yoshi

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutter...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutters, you can be a Super Mario Bro. yourself and make adorable Mario themed goodies! Can be used with fondant for icing cakes, making cookie dough cutouts, or even topping pies! Make cookies, breads, or pastries with your very own cute Mario themed cookie Sets! Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to poss...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Nintendo Handheld Cookie Cutters - Gameboy, Gameboy Advanced, Switch Lite, DS, S

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Your childhood brought to life in beautiful edible form, make some controllers, eat some controllers. Just dont decorate them like MadCatz ;) Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to possible cross contamination, allergy, and food use issues. All sales are final on this product, regardless of opened or unopened status. This is for the health of all our customer...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Mario Kart Cookie Cutters - Banana, Blooper, Bob-Omb, Bullet Bill, Pow Block

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutter...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutters, you can be a Super Mario Bro. yourself and make adorable Mario themed goodies! Can be used with fondant for icing cakes, making cookie dough cutouts, or even topping pies! Make cookies, breads, or pastries with your very own cute Mario themed cookie Sets! Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to poss...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Power Star Items Cookie Cutters - 8 Bit Power Star, Grand Star, Power Moon, Power Star, Shine Sprite

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake You've collected them for years but now you can eat them! Enjoy these iconic Mario items that still power-up our favorite plumber to this day! Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to possible cross contamination, allergy, and food use issues. All sales are final on this product, regardless of opened or unopened status. This is for the health of all our custome...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Mario Numbers & Letters! FONT Cookie Cutters - Fondant Letters

These fonts will be produced mirrored, so that when cutting the cookies normally, the letters wil...

These fonts will be produced mirrored, so that when cutting the cookies normally, the letters will be the right way around. This set photographed was made special to show off the font in a readable way. Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to possible cross contamination, allergy, and food use issues. All sales are final on this product, regardless of opened or unopened status. This is for the health of all our customers, thank you for your understanding! ITS A' ME, COOKIE M...

$30.95 (2 variants)

Mario Odyssey Cookie Cutters - Toad, Shy Guy, Koopa Troopa Boo

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutter...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutters, you can be a Super Mario Bro. yourself and make adorable Mario themed goodies! Can be used with fondant for icing cakes, making cookie dough cutouts, or even topping pies! Make cookies, breads, or pastries with your very own cute Mario themed cookie Sets! Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to poss...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Mario Villains Cookie Cutters - Wario, Waluigi, Birdo, Poochy, Sniffit

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutter...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutters, you can be a Super Mario Bro. yourself and make adorable Mario themed goodies! Can be used with fondant for icing cakes, making cookie dough cutouts, or even topping pies! Make cookies, breads, or pastries with your very own cute Mario themed cookie Sets! Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to poss...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Paper Mario TTYD Friends Cookie Cutters- Goombella, Lady Bow, Madame Flurrie, Vivian TTYD, Yoshi Kid

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutter...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutters, you can be a Super Mario Bro. yourself and make adorable Mario themed goodies! Can be used with fondant for icing cakes, making cookie dough cutouts, or even topping pies! Make cookies, breads, or pastries with your very own cute Mario themed cookie Sets! Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to poss...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Nintendo Game CartridgeCookie Cutters - Gameboy, N64, NES, SNES

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to possible cross contamination, allergy, and food use issues. All sales are final on this product, regardless of opened or unopened status. This is for the health of all our customers, thank you for your understanding! Item Details: Hand designed and tested to make the coolest cookies around :D Food Safe and Top Rack dish...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Paper Mario TTYD Villains Cookie Cutters- Doopliss, Grodus Head, Lord Crump, Pirate Cortez, Shadow Queen

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/...

Mix and Match Cookie Cutter Sets HERE Find our baking recipe and tips here! https://lootcave.com/blogs/news/how2bake ITS A ME, COOKIE MARIO! With these super cute cookie cutters, you can be a Super Mario Bro. yourself and make adorable Mario themed goodies! Can be used with fondant for icing cakes, making cookie dough cutouts, or even topping pies! Make cookies, breads, or pastries with your very own cute Mario themed cookie Sets! Please note that cookie cutters CANNOT be returned due to poss...

$11.95 $30.95 (6 variants)

Refine

Category